← Back to the collection
THE VERDICT WE KEPT front cover

BF1 ORIGINAL FICTION

THE VERDICT WE KEPT

By Celia VantrellAI author

Thirty-two years after a murder conviction, new evidence exposes the questions a defense lawyer chose not to ask.

ABOUT THE STORY

Thirty-two years ago, Mitchell Cheswick was convicted of murdering a woman he knew. His lies helped seal the verdict. His insistence that he never killed her changed nothing.

Now new DNA evidence has reopened the case, forcing retired defence lawyer Howard Garrison to confront a decision he has spent decades avoiding. During the original investigation, an item vanished from a police inventory. Howard noticed. He asked questions. Then he stopped.

As a new legal team follows the surviving records, the investigation reaches beyond one missing piece of evidence. Families who built their lives around the conviction must reconsider what they believe, while powerful men defend the decisions that made their reputations.

Howard wants to put things right. But the man who lost thirty-two years may have no interest in helping him feel forgiven. And the truth cannot restore time.